Skip to content
Alpha Poker Online

Elon Musk's X Secures Appeal to Restore Viewing for Australian Users to Charlie Kirk Shooting Footage

Following a significant legal reversal, the Australian classification review board has reversed a prior decision that prevented Australian-based users from accessing video footage of the violent event involving influencer Charlie Kirk. The appeal was lodged by Elon Musk's social media platform, which contested an order issued at the request of the online safety regulator.

Details of the Original Classification Ruling

Following the death of Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University in last year, the regulator applied to the classification board to officially classify the circulating video. The board initially ruled the content was "refused classification", a rating that empowered the regulator to order platforms to restrict access to the posts for users in Australia.

The platform X filed an appeal for a pair of videos depicting the Kirk incident. It also appealed a similar ruling on another piece of footage—showing the attack on Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte—which had also been classified as "refused classification".

Arguments Presented and Final Ruling

Arguing its case, X asserted that the footage in question contained only a short moment of violence with the weapon not shown. It was argued the footage was grainy and the focus shifted rapidly from the victim to the surrounding crowd.

The social media giant maintained the footage was not overly graphic, gratuitous, or objectionable, stating it served as a neutral objective record of "a significant incident of historical and political significance that prompted widespread discussion". The platform even compared the video and the historic film of the JFK shooting.

Most members of the review board ultimately agreed that, "despite the terrible nature of the event," the video did not reach a level that was gratuitous, exploitative or offensive enough to warrant a 'refused classification' rating. The board suggested that a more detailed depiction with alternative commentary might have resulted in a different ruling. Consequently, the board changed the rating of the videos to R18+.

The Minority Opinion

Some on the board disagreed, arguing the post was "a shareable video for the probable aim of amusement and/or benefit (such as likes, shares, or views)". They also argued the parallel with the JFK assassination tape was invalid, as the Kennedy video was released years after the assassination, "after public sentiment around the matter had subsided".

Reactions to the Decision

Posting on its official policy channel, X expressed approval of the ruling.

"We challenged this case to defend free speech and the critical nature of public access about issues of public interest. Our commitment remains dedicated to protecting these principles."

Representatives for the eSafety commissioner acknowledged the board's decision, but noted that the revised classification now implies platforms "must take steps to ensure R18+ material being displayed to Australians who are minors".

Recent Developments on Violent Content

Separately, the eSafety commissioner did not issue take-down orders to social media companies this week regarding disturbing videos from the Sydney beach incident shared across social media. Officials commented that while the images were distressing, they did not reach the high threshold for a "total ban" rating.

Instead, platforms have been advised to use sensitive content labels and interstitials, such as blurring, on this material in accordance with their own content policies.

Written by

Leslie Barnes

A professional poker strategist with over a decade of experience in online tournaments and coaching.

Alpha Poker Online

Type to search articles.